Before moving to Portland, I spent most of my time in Boothbay Harbor. My family had a log cabin right on the coast, and I spent many summers enjoying my little slice of heaven. As most of the town is open during the summer, Boothbay Harbor is the perfect vacation destination.
The food in Boothbay Harbor is phenomenal, and I always struggle to decide where I should eat. However, when it comes to eating breakfast, there is no doubt in my mind that I’m heading to Mama D’s. Open year round, Mama D’s serves breakfast and lunch, and serves a variety of beverages. The café is small and intimate, and the atmosphere is warm and friendly. While indoor seating is available year round, Mama D’s has a patio where outdoor seating is set up during the summer months. Chairs can be found on the porch as well, and the view is spectacular. My go to meal is a sizable waffle, along with a cup of coffee. The waffle is filling and delicious, and one free refill comes to those who order a coffee. Something to note is that Mama D’s only accepts cash and check, so make sure to plan accordingly.
Boat House Bistro is another restaurant that is open year round. As it happens, there are three floors available for guests, and each offers a different experience. The first floor is entirely indoors, while the second floor offers both indoor and outdoor seating. The third and final floor offers a completely alfresco experience. A beautiful view of the harbor can be enjoyed, and umbrellas offer a respite from the sun. During the winter, the first two floors are open; to keep patrons warm during the Maine winter.

The menu is extensive, to say the least. Hot and cold tapas, along with salads, soups and risotto can all be found, along with seafood and a more land based diet. Speaking to the servers revealed that the chef is known for his risotto, making it his signature dish. While I was enjoying my caser salad and wings, I caught sight of a bartender making a drink for another customer. I discovered that the cocktail was called a Blue Berry Sangria, and it was incredible. While there were hints of this berry infused within the cocktail, the bartender added a couple of blueberries to the drink, which highlighted an already great flavor. Boat House Bistro is also located by the footbridge, which connects both sides of the harbor, enabling easy transport from a highly residential area of Boothbay Harbor to the downtown area. Boat House Bistro accepts credit cards as well as cash, so there is a lot more flexibility when it comes to payment.

The Tugboat Restaurant is another great experience in the culinary experience that is Boothbay Harbor. Much of the restaurant is a converted tugboat, and the interior is cozy and homey. The view from within the restaurant is incredible, with the harbor and it’s islands giving a sense of relaxation. The main restaurant has plenty of tables, and the food is great. I’m particularly fond of their caesar salad and lobster bisque, so I recommend either one. While I haven’t had a chance to check out the lounge, the Tugboat’s website has a list of events that the restaurant and lounge are hosting.
McSeagulls is another main stay in Boothbay Harbor. Located right on the pier, McSeagulls offers the typical pub fare, as well as seafood. A full bar is also available, with plenty of beers and liquor available. Tables, booths, and seats at the bar are all available indoors year round, and outside when the weather is warm. The deck has it’s own bar and provides an extraordinary view of the harbor. During the summer months, live entertainment can be enjoyed throughout the week. There’s plenty to eat at McSeagulls, as they have a wide assortment of food available. Whether you love seafood, pizza, pub fare or salads, McSeagulls has you covered.
Dunton’s Dog House is a hidden gem in Boothbay Harbor. Tucked away just outside of the downtown area, this roadside eatery is perfect for lunch or dinner. Dunton’s, to the untrained eye, might seem out of place compared to other eating establishments. Food is prepared in a red shed, and customers can have their food prepared to go, or eat it on one of the picnic tables behind the restaurant. Vending machines are found by Dunton’s, with an assortment of Pepsi products available for sale. Dunton’s Dog House boasts an impressive menu featuring seafood and typical American fare. Now, many of you might be thinking that such a place wouldn’t be a “decent” place to purchase seafood. However, one bite of their lobster roll will dispel any reservations about the quality of their food. With classic rock playing in the background, any meal at Dunton’s will provide an enjoyable experience. Just be mindful that Dunton’s Dog House is only open from April to October, and they only accept cash.
Pier 1 Pizza and Pub is another mainstay in Boothbay Harbor. Located right on the pier, Pier 1 Pizza serves a wide assortment of pizza, as well as sandwiches, calzones, and salads. Open year round, customers can eat their food inside, or take it right onto the wharf, where there are picnic tables set up for tourists to enjoy the view. The pub next door is part of Pier 1 Pizza, and a door between the pizzeria and the bar connects the two businesses. High tops and seats at the bar provide patrons a respite from their adventures, as well as a place to eat their pizza if they’re hungry. While guests can’t take their drinks right onto the wharf, the Pier 1 Pub does have outdoor seating available. For the Red Sox fans among you, this is the place for you. Red Sox memorabilia is scattered around the walls, while the patio resembles The Big Green Monster from Fenway Park. Finally, a jukebox can be found within the bar, allowing guests to play a whole slew of songs.
Dessert is in no short supply in Boothbay Harbor, and there are plenty of options. The Downeast Ice Cream Factory is perfectly positioned on the wharf, and offers a wide variety of flavors. Sundaes and other such delicacies are also available for purchase. A map of the U.S. is found on the wall along with pins, so guests can show just how far they travelled to visit Maine. The Downeast Ice Cream Factory even opened a second location in a plaza that sits on the way in and out of Boothbay Harbor, so if your sweet tooth acts up on the way home, you can make the stop without going out of your way.


Another great place to satisfy your sweet tooth is Downeast Candies. Two stores rolled into one, Downeast Candies is made up of the Fudge Factory and Daffy Taffy. The fudge and taffy are both made in house, and both are delicious. The fudge comes in a small assortment of flavors, including plain chocolate, chocolate mint, peanut butter, and chocolate peanut butter. The taffy’s assortment of flavors is mind-boggling. Chocolate, vanilla, orange and so much more cover the wall. The equipment needed to make the taffy is set up behind glass paneling, enabling guests to see how taffy is made. The final step in making taffy is wrapping this confectionary in wax. The machine that works on this task is able to wrap about 144 pieces of taffy per minute!


Eating in Boothbay Harbor is an adventure all on its own, and I thoroughly enjoyed my self. If you want to learn more about Mama D’s click on here, while information on Boat House Bistro can be found here. Information on the Tugboat can be found here, while McSeagulls can be found here. Finally, Dunton’s Dog House can be found here, while Pier 1 Pizza can be found here. I’ve barely scratched the surface when it comes to eating in Boothbay Harbor, but there is a silver lining, in that I have a reason to go back, and continue my culinary journey. Make sure you stay tuned, as activities you can do in Boothbay Harbor is coming soon.
On a more somber note, I regret to say that my grandmother, Ann Maude, has passed away. When she married my grandfather in 1972, the cabin in Boothbay Harbor became a major part of her life. When I was born, I felt a special connection to Boothbay Harbor, and to the state of Maine. My time at the cabin, the summers I spent at sleep away camp in Raymond, and my eventual move to Portland, stem from my grandmother. She was a loving woman with a great sense of humor. I will miss her, but I know she is in a better place.
























